Best PC versions of console games: recomps and ports compared

Which recomp, decomp or native port is the best way to play each console game on PC, scored on graphics, player reports, completeness and upkeep.

Recomp comparisons: the best PC version of each console game

Key facts

  • Many console games now have more than one fan-made PC version: recompilations, decompilations and native ports.
  • Each comparison scores every Windows version out of 100: graphics and features 30, player reports 30, playable to the end 20, upkeep 15 and achievements 5.
  • Player reports and version data come from Quiver Launcher's public catalog; close calls are reviewed by hand.
  • You always need your own copy of the original game. No ROMs or ISOs are linked.
Platforms
Windows

Fan projects have brought hundreds of console games to PC as native programs, without an emulator. For popular games there’s often more than one: a recompilation, a decompilation, a port with its own launcher… and they’re not equally good. These comparisons look at every Windows version of a game and recommend one.

Comparisons

GameOriginal consoleRecommended PC versionScoreVersions compared
Banjo-KazooieNintendo 64Lighthouse76.93
Bayonetta 3Nintendo SwitchWitch Time67.72
Blast CorpsNintendo 64Power Dozer67.52
BloodbornePlayStation 4Bloodborne for Windows79.34
Burnout 3: TakedownXboxTakedawn82.82
Crash of the TitansXbox 360CrashRecomp: Crash of the Titans, Definitive Edition (PC)70.33
Crash Team Racing: Nitro-FueledPlayStation 4OCTR: Online CTR Nitro-Fueled PC71.42
Dead or Alive 3XboxDOA3 Recomp72.32
Diddy Kong RacingNintendo 64DKR-R63.92
Digimon WorldPlayStationDigimon World — Recompiled63.12
Donkey Kong 64Nintendo 64DK64 Rekongpiled61.92
Duke Nukem: Zero HourNintendo 64Duke Nukem Zero Hour: Recompiled36.01
F-Zero XNintendo 64G-Diffuser88.12
GoldenEye 007 (XBLA)Xbox 360GoldenEye 007 XBLA PC Recomp61.52
Gravity Rush 2PlayStation 4GRport72.33
Gravity Rush RemasteredPlayStation 4Gravity Rush Remastered Native PC Port69.53
Jet Force GeminiNintendo 64Jet Force Gemini: Recompiled66.32
Mario Kart 64Nintendo 64SpaghettiKart75.52
MediEvil (2019)PlayStation 4MediEvil (PS4) for PC62.62
Metroid Prime HuntersNintendo DSSecond Hunt67.03
Pilotwings 64Nintendo 64Birdman6459.22
Ratchet & ClankPlayStation 2RAC-RS76.95
Shadow the HedgehogXboxShadow Recompiled58.22
Soulcalibur IIGameCubeRing Out85.32
Star Fox 64Nintendo 64Starship70.12
Stunt Race FXSuper NintendoStunt Race FX Remastered66.82
Super Mario 64Nintendo 64Ghostship72.34
Super Mario GalaxyWiiNebula72.72
Super Mario WorldSuper NintendoSuperMarioWorldRecomp61.24
Super MetroidSuper NintendoSuperMetroidSNESRecomp55.73
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the PastSuper Nintendosnesrev: Zelda 3 Launcher62.75
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask 3DNintendo 3DSDekUI69.32
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeNintendo 64Ship of Harkinian79.02
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3DNintendo 3DSTriAevum67.72
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight PrincessGameCubeDusklight76.52
Uncharted: The Nathan Drake CollectionPlayStation 4Uncharted: The Nathan Drake Collection - PC port82.93
WETXbox 360WET Recompiled81.33
Wipeout XLPlayStationWipeout XL Rewrite65.62

How the scores work

Every Windows version of a game in Quiver’s catalog gets a score out of 100:

Criterion Points What counts
Graphics and features 30 16:9 and ultrawide, higher resolution, HD textures, fullscreen, unlocked frame rate, mod support. 16:9 counts double for 2D consoles (NES, SNES, GBA, Mega Drive).
Player reports 30 Reviews on Quiver: works, works with issues, doesn’t work.
Playable to the end 20 Whether its README and reviews say the whole game can be finished.
Upkeep 15 Latest release and commit, stars; an archived repository scores 0.
Achievements 5 Built-in achievements or trophies.

Emulators, modified emulators, launchers and Mac-only ports are left out, even when the catalog lists them as Windows apps. When the top two are within 5 points, or the leader has a known problem, the comparison is reviewed by hand and the verdict says so.

Good to know

  • You need your own copy of the game. Recomps and ports only replace the game’s code; the graphics, sound and levels come from the original that you provide. MrScion never links ROMs or ISOs.
  • Quiver Launcher is the easiest way to install and update these projects, and where the player reports come from.
  • New comparisons are added to the table above as they’re published.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between a recomp, a decomp and a port?

A recompilation translates the console's machine code into native PC code automatically. A decompilation rebuilds the game's source code by hand so it can be compiled for PC. A native port is any version rewritten or adapted to run directly on PC. All three run without an emulator.

Why isn't the highest score always the recommendation?

Scores are calculated automatically. When two versions are close, or the top one has a known problem (it's really an emulator, it can't be finished yet), the comparison is reviewed by hand and the verdict explains why.

How often is this updated?

The scores reflect Quiver's catalog on the review date shown in each comparison. Projects change fast, so comparisons are revisited when a new version changes the picture.